I’ve always defended the acting on the show. I usually say something like “Did you see them talk fast? Rory, show them how you talk fast.” There is one scene that is supposed to be serious but makes me laugh every time. It takes place in Season 4 in the episode “Nag Hammadi is where They Found the Gnostic Gospels” It’s the scene where a drunk Luke goes to fix Lorelai’s window and has a ranting fit about what Jess said to him and accidentally cuts his hand. I live in Utah & Luke isn’t even a convincing drunk to me. It’s the worst acting I’ve seen on any show ever. I can only assume that he taught April how to cry. What do you think is the worst acting on Gilmore Girls?